Exploring Hip-Hop Pedagogies in Music Education

Over the weekend I went to a hip-hop education panel organized and moderated by my fellow white hip-hop advocate Jamie Ehrenfeld, featuring four of the brightest lights in the field: Jamel Mims aka MC Tingbudong (rapper in English and Mandarin), Dizzy Senze (devastatingly great freestyle rapper), Regan Sommer McCoy (curator of the Mixtape Museum), and Marlon Richardson, aka UnLearn the World (another devastatingly great freestyle rapper). Several other emcees showed up, including one of my main hip-hop peer educators, Roman The Mafioso, pictured below.

After the panel, all the emcees got into a cypher. At first they were rapping over a DJ, while a few NYU kids tried to play along on saxophones and piano. Then the DJ paused and folks tried rapping over just the NYU music students’ instrumental accompaniment. Roman gently trolled the NYU kids: “Keep it steady, keep it steady.” They did better when Steff Reed jumped on the piano and replaced their uncertain jazz with thumping gospel. Listening to this, I felt what I always feel in a cypher: that freestyle rap is the most advanced and sophisticated form of music I have ever heard in my life.

Continue reading “Exploring Hip-Hop Pedagogies in Music Education”

Dissertation summary

I applied for something that asked for a ten page summary of my doctoral dissertation. Maybe you would like to read it, rather than the full 300 pages?

Learning Something Deep: Teaching to Learn and Learning to Teach Hip-Hop in New York City (summary)

Image: Toni Blackman leads a middle school songwriting workshop

In this dissertation, I present a narrative of learning to teach hip-hop, and of teaching to learn hip-hop. I document my process of learning hip-hop music education methods from practitioners, and of teaching music education students with those methods. The narrative begins with my inquiry into how hip-hop might best be included in school music programs, or more specifically, into the preparation of pre-service music teachers. I profile three hip-hop educators: teachers and teaching artists whose practice uses hip-hop music, aesthetics, and values to advance social justice goals. I then discuss putting these educators’ approaches into practice in a music education course that I taught at New York University. I examine the experiences and perspectives of students in this course in order to assess its effectiveness. Finally, I use all of the above to inform my proposed suggestions for the roles that hip-hop might play in university-level music education programs generally.

Throughout the study, I ask the following questions: What is hip-hop music education? What are its goals? What are its methods? How do we practice it ethically? In order to answer these questions, along with additional related and emergent questions, I situate the study in the larger context of popular music pedagogy in high schools, in teaching artist practices in school and community settings, and in the university programs that prepare teachers to do this work. I explore the role that hip-hop methods can play in the preparation of pre-service music educators. In particular, I examine the ways that hip-hop music education can support critical praxis and challenge the white racial frame of American music education.

Continue reading “Dissertation summary”

Polymeter vs polyrhythm

As I continue to build groove pedagogy resources, I want to clear up some persistent confusion about polymeter and polyrhythm. If you don’t feel like reading the whole post, it can be summed up in this image:

The most concisely I can put this into words:

  • In polymeter, the grid lines are aligned, but the downbeats aren’t.
  • In polyrhythm, the downbeats are aligned, but the grid lines aren’t.

Continue reading “Polymeter vs polyrhythm”

New Orff arrangements with Heather Fortune

Heather Fortune and I are delighted to announce the publication of 5 Pop Grooves for Orff Ensemble, available now from the good people at F-flat Books. If you teach elementary music, you should check them out!

We discuss the process behind and purpose of this music on F-flat’s podcast:

The arrangements grew out of a series of groove-oriented instrumental method books that Heather and I are working on. As we were building our collection of grooves and patterns, Heather realized that some of them would work well as Orff music. I wrote the (very silly) lyrics. The pieces are structured around repetitive grooves that build gradually in complexity – read more about that idea here. You can play them as through-composed pieces, or you can use them as modular kits for assembling your own music.

Continue reading “New Orff arrangements with Heather Fortune”

We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together

I was not expecting to write a post on here about Taylor Swift. I have nothing against her and wish her the best, I’m just not her target audience. But when you have kids, you find yourself in all kinds of new situations. Ever since my daughter started second grade, she has gone from mildly Taylor-curious to being a full-blown Swiftie. We’ve been listening to the greatest hits together, and so far, “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together” is the one I like the best. It’s from Taylor’s 2012 album Red, and it was her first number one Billboard hit. She co-wrote and co-produced it with Max Martin and Shellback.

Taylor also released a version for country radio. It has the banjo mixed louder, it lacks the backwards guitar parts and synth swooshes, and the drums don’t have such a conspicuously electronic timbre. I think the pop version is better. 

Continue reading “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together”

Freedom Jazz Dance

A friend texted me to tell me that he was listening to a jazz show on public radio in Denver, and that they referenced an old blog post of mine about “Freedom Jazz Dance” by Eddie Harris. That was a pleasant surprise, and it made me want to go back to the post and freshen it up. So here are some new thoughts about what is arguably the weirdest jazz standard.

To be clear, there are many weirder jazz tunes than this, but not in the core repertoire. Also, “weird” does not mean “complex”. This tune is radical in its simplicity. In fact, it is so radically simple that usually when other people play it, they insert more structure into it. It illustrates the surprising fact that the simpler a tune is, the harder it can be for jazz musicians to improvise on it. We will get to this idea in more depth below.

Continue reading “Freedom Jazz Dance”

Artificial intelligence in music

We are kicking off my Musical Borrowing class at the New School with a discussion of artificial intelligence in music. I decided to start here because 1) we are covering concepts in reverse chronological order; 2) the students are going to want to talk about it anyway; and 3) this is the least interesting topic of the course for me personally, so I’d prefer to get it out of the way. To get everybody oriented, I assigned this mostly optimistic take on AI music from Ableton’s web site. Then we did some in-class listening and discussion.

Continue reading “Artificial intelligence in music”

Don’t You Worry ‘Bout A Thing

Every ten years it occurs to me to learn this tune, and then I come up against the fact that it’s in E-flat minor, I get discouraged, and I give up. Well, not this time! This time I decided to take the coward’s way out: I put the tune in Ableton and transposed it up to the much more guitarist-friendly key of E minor. 

Yusuf Roahman plays shaker and Sheila Wilkerson plays bongos and güiro, and Stevie plays everything else: piano, (synth) bass and drums. I assume that Stevie put down the piano first and then they overdubbed everything on top?

Continue reading “Don’t You Worry ‘Bout A Thing”

Musical Borrowing syllabus

This fall I’m teaching Musical Borrowing from Plainchant to Sampling at the New School for the first time. Here’s my syllabus. It will probably evolve as we go, but this is the initial plan.

This course on “non-original” music explores how frequently existing compositions have been appropriated and adapted into new works, and how these borrowings challenge conventional notions of originality and authenticity. The course provides historical perspectives on musical borrowing from the Renaissance through 19th-century paraphrases and 20th-century cover versions to debates about sampling and plagiarism cases today. It explores the evolving cultural, philosophical, legal, and economic considerations around the phenomenon of musical borrowing. Students engage with these topics through guided listenings, readings, response papers, quizzes, class presentations, and creative projects, with a final research/analysis paper on a recent/current case of musical borrowing. A basic knowledge of music theory and some ability to read music notation are helpful but not required for this course.

Continue reading “Musical Borrowing syllabus”

Dies irae

This fall I’m teaching Musical Borrowing from Plainchant to Sampling at the New School. For the plainchant part of that, my example is the Dies irae sequence, which is to Western European classical music what the Funky Drummer break is to hip-hop. Dies irae (Latin for “the day of wrath”) is a medieval poem describing the Last Judgment from the Book of Revelation. Its first musical setting was a Gregorian chant in Dorian mode from the 13th century.

Fun fact! In Monty Python and the Holy Grail, the self-flagellating monks are chanting the last few lines of the Dies irae sequence.

Continue reading “Dies irae”